With the processing of PEC 45 in the Federal Senate, civil society organizations came together to express their support for a 3S tax reform: healthy, solidarity-based and sustainable. More than 130 entities launched a manifesto on Tuesday (10), addressed to senators, expressing concern about the lobbying of industries of products harmful to health and the environment that are trying to undermine and sabotage the selective tax and press for tax exemptions and benefits. The manifesto can be accessed at: https://pelacidadania.org.br/reforma-tributaria-3s/
Also known as the "sin tax," the selective tax aims to increase taxation and discourage the consumption of products that cause harm to society and negative externalities – such as tobacco products, alcoholic beverages, ultra-processed products, pesticides, fossil fuels and air pollutants, firearms, revolvers, pistols, and ammunition.
The manifesto also calls for reduced tax rates and preferential tax treatment to be reserved only for products that promote health and environmental protection, such as essential basic food items, products from socio-biodiversity and family farming, agricultural bio-inputs, personal hygiene products and medicines, and products for basic menstrual health care.
The manifesto for a 3S tax reform: healthy, supportive, and sustainable is spearheaded by ACT Promoção da Saúde, Instituto Democracia e Sustentabilidade (IDS), Instituto de Estudos Socioeconômicos (Inesc), OXFAM Brasil, Ação da Cidadania, Associação Brasileira de Saúde Coletiva (Abrasco), Campanha Nacional Contra os Agrotóxicos e Pela Vida, Instituto Ethos, Instituto Internacional de Educação do Brasil (IEB), Instituto Sociedade, População e Natureza (ISPN), Observatório das Economias da Sociobiodiversidade (ÓSocioBio) – and, among the signatory organizations are Pastoral da Terra, Movimento Todos Juntos Contra o Câncer, Greenpeace, WWF Brasil, among dozens of other national and local entities in the fields of health, environment, and social justice.
See below for the full text of the manifesto, followed by a complete list of signatory organizations.
Tax Reform Manifesto 3S for the Senate
We, the undersigned organizations, through the 3S Tax Reform articulation – Healthy, Solidarity-based and Sustainable – celebrate the progress of the Tax Reform in the Federal Senate. However, we believe that the text can be improved by incorporating demands from Brazilian society so that the reform is more aligned with 21st-century economies, environmental justice, the necessary just energy transition, and the promotion of public health.
We are particularly concerned about the pressure from certain economic sectors to ensure the maintenance of their tax benefits and to attack the Selective Tax. If the text passes as it stands today, products such as pesticides, ultra-processed foods, and weapons will be constitutionally eligible to receive tax incentives.
Selective taxation aims to increase taxation and discourage the consumption of products that harm society. Tax incentives, on the other hand, should boost the energy transition, combat hunger with real food, and promote public health, and cannot encourage, through reduced rates, the trade of products that go in the opposite direction.
There is already a consensus in public opinion on the need for a Selective Tax: 94% of the Brazilian population is in favor of increasing taxes on products harmful to health and the environment , according to a Datafolha survey. Congress needs to respond to the population's desires, ensuring the approval of the Selective Tax as approved in the Chamber of Deputies, and preventing products that cause harm to health, the environment, and the climate from being favored with tax benefits.
Beyond the issue of the Selective Tax, we also understand that the resources to be made available by the Regional Development Fund must be aligned with the Ecological Transition Plan. It is necessary to ensure that the stimulus to regional development prioritizes the promotion of productive activities or investments in sustainable infrastructure that are consistent with the National Policy on Climate Change (PNMC) and the National Strategy and Action Plan for Biodiversity (EPANB).
We believe that the role of federated entities is important for improving climate and socio-environmental governance, and therefore we also advocate for the replacement of the Ecological ICMS (Tax on Circulation of Goods and Services) with the Ecological IBS (Tax on Goods and Services), since it is a successful policy that has benefited 18 states and thousands of municipalities for 30 years, especially small ones and those furthest from urban centers, with significant volumes of environmental compensation.
Therefore, through this manifesto, we ask the Senators to:
- Maintain the selective tax as a tool to discourage the consumption of harmful products. to health, the environment and the climate, such as: Pesticides, Fossil Fuels and Air Pollutants, Tobacco Products, Ultra-processed Foods, Alcoholic Beverages, Firearms, revolvers, pistols and ammunition;
- Include in Reduced rates only apply to products that promote health and environmental protection., such as: products from the National Basic Food Basket, foods essential to human health, products from socio-biodiversity and family farming, agricultural bio-inputs, personal hygiene products and medicines, and products for basic menstrual health care;
- Strengthen the productive arrangements and the capacity for social and economic organization of family farmers and their legally equivalent entities, including specific treatment for their associations and cooperatives;
- Ensure that the Products subject to the selective tax cannot benefit from tax incentives.;
- Link the collection of the selective tax to public health actions and services;
- Replace the current Ecological ICMS with IBS Ecological, thus preserving a successful policy that benefits local actions for sustainability;
- Ensure that the resources allocated to the Regional Development Fund are aligned with the Ecological Transition Plan, with the National Policy on Climate Change (PNMC) and with National Strategy and Action Plan for Biodiversity (ESBAN).
They sign:
Abrasco – Brazilian Public Health Association
Citizenship Action
ACT Health Promotion
Campanha Permanente Contra os Agrotóxicos and Pela Vida
IDS – Institute for Democracy and Sustainability
IEB – International Institute of Education of Brazil
Inesc – Institute of Socioeconomic Studies
Ethos Institute of Business and Social Responsibility
ISPN – Institute for Society, Population and Nature
OCA – Brazil Nut Observatory
ÓSocioBio – Observatory of Sociobiodiversity Economies
Oxfam Brazil
Full list of signatories:
| 350.org Brazil |
| Citizenship Action |
| AIMURIK Association |
| ACT Health Promotion |
| Aguapé Association of rubber tappers of the Guaporé Valley |
| APIZ – Association of the Zoró Indigenous People |
| Agro-extractive and Tourist Association of Barra do Tapajós |
| Terrazul Alternative Association |
| Ayrumã Association |
| Brazilian Association of Agroecology |
| Brazilian Association of Lymphoma and Leukemia |
| Brazilian Collective Health Association |
| Mayrob Indigenous Village Community Association |
| Community Association of Rural Producers of the Braço Community |
| Association of Crochet Makers of Areial |
| Boa Esperança Agro-extractive Residents Association |
| Jatuarana Residents Association |
| Association for the Preservation of the Environment and Life |
| Rikbaktsa Indigenous People's Association |
| Jiahui People's Association |
| Celiac Association of Espírito Santo |
| Association of Extractivists of the Iriri River, Maribel |
| Association of Miners and Small Rural Producers and Extractivists of the Repartimento dos Pilões Community |
| Association of Agro-extractive Residents of the Guariba Roosevelt/Rio Roosevelt Extractive Reserve |
| Association of Agro-extractive Residents of the Communities of São Raimundo Pedra Branca Cafezal Recreio and Panamá in the Parú Region |
| Residents' Association of the Arioca Pruanã Extractive Reserve |
| Association of Residents and Agro-extractive Producers of the Tefé National Forest and Surrounding Area |
| Association of Indigenous Peoples of Mapuera |
| Association of the Wai Wai Xaary Indigenous Peoples |
| Association of Agro-extractive Producers of the Assembly of God of Vila Limeira – APAVIL |
| Association of Agro-extractive Producers of Canutama – ASPAC |
| Association of Agro-extractive Producers and Processors of Beruri |
| Association of Chestnut Producers and Processors of the Municipality of Amatura |
| Association of MPDFT Employees (Asmip) |
| Association of Rural Workers of Juruá |
| Association of the Witotos of the Upper Solimões |
| Kawaiwete Indigenous Association |
| Pykore Indigenous Association |
| Zavidjaj Djiguhr Indigenous Association |
| TSIRIK Indigenous Rikbaktsa Association |
| Metareilá Association of the Paiter Surui Indigenous People |
| Golden Lion Tamarin Association |
| Mixed Agricultural and Extractive Association of the Jaramacaru Community and Region |
| Quilombola and Extractive Association of the Vila de Joana Peres Community |
| São Luiz II Association |
| Tururukari-uka Association of the Kambeba Indians |
| Associates of Silves for Environmental and Cultural Preservation |
| Bay Kayapó Cooperative of Forest Products |
| Caapora Bem Viver – Urban Permaculture Station |
| Capricol Cooperative of Goat and Sheep Producers of Eastern Cariri LTDA |
| CEDENPA – Center for Studies and Defense of Black People of Pará |
| Afro Center for the Promotion and Defense of Life Father Ezequiel Rami |
| Paiter Wagoh Pakob Indigenous Cultural Center |
| Center for Support of Community Action Projects - CEAPAC |
| Center for Defense and Environmental Education |
| Center for Studies and Promotion of Group Agriculture |
| Pachamama Spiritual Center |
| International Center for Water and Transdisciplinarity |
| No Fracking Brazil Coalition |
| Why eat? |
| Pastoral Land Commission |
| General Council of the Hixkaryana People |
| National Council of Extractive Populations – CNS |
| Agro-extractive Cooperative of Mapia and Middle Purus |
| Extractive Cooperative of the Urubutinga Community |
| Zoró Indigenous People's Production Cooperative |
| Cooperative of Workers in the Solidarity Economy of Recyclable Material Collectors from the Lagoas do Norte Territory |
| Cooperative of Processors of Agro-extractive Products of the Municipality of Amaturá |
| Sardinha Mixed Agro-extractive Cooperative |
| Mixed Workers' Cooperative Casa do Cerrado |
| Mixed Cooperative of Settled Family Farmers of Northwest Minas Gerais |
| Regional Cooperative Based on Family Farming and Extractive Activities |
| Federation of Traditional Communities of the Tapajós National Forest |
| Unicafes Bahia Federation |
| Environmental Action and Defense Force |
| Sergipe State Forum on Solidarity Economy |
| NCD Forum – Intersectoral Forum for Combating NCDs in Brazil |
| Guanabara Gazette |
| Gestures (HIV-positive status, Communication, and Gender) |
| Greenpeace Brazil |
| Study, Research and Practice Group in Food Environment and Health |
| Nutrition and Poverty Research Group, Institute for Advanced Studies – IEA-USP |
| Amazon Working Group |
| Ibfan BR Network in Defense of the Right to Breastfeed |
| Brazilian Institute for Consumer Protection – Idec |
| 5 Elements Institute – Education for Sustainability |
| Cerrado Bioregional Institute |
| EcoVida Institute |
| Equit Institute |
| Esperancita Institute |
| Federal Institute of Maranhão |
| Arayara International Institute |
| Juruá Institute |
| Krehawa Institute |
| Munduruku Institute |
| Socio-environmental Institute |
| Terroá Institute |
| Life and Light Institute |
| Food and Nutrition Education Laboratory (LEAN) |
| Active Life Laboratory |
| Mater Natura – Institute of Environmental Studies |
| Unicops |
| MOVIECO – Ecological Movement |
| Paulo Jackson Movement for Justice and Democracies |
| People's Health Movement/Brazil |
| SOS Chapada dos Veadeiros Movement |
| Movement All Together Against Cancer |
| Center for Agroecology Studies of the Federal Institute of Goiás – Hidrolândia Advanced Campus |
| Nucleus of Pequi and Other Fruits of the Cerrado |
| Observatory of Justice and Conservation |
| Coal Observatory |
| Oil and Gas Observatory |
| Organization of Indigenous Peoples of the Upper Madeira – OPIAM |
| Organization of Rubber Tappers of Rondônia |
| Water Pact |
| Agroecology and Family Farming Network of Bom Despacho and Region |
| Faith, Peace and Climate Network |
| Rural Workers' Union of Lábrea |
| Monte Coruscante Farm |
| Union of Family Farming and Solidarity Economy Cooperatives (Unicafes RS) |
| Unicatadores |
| WWF-Brazil |